Friday, December 4, 2015


Throne of Glass
Sarah J. Maas
Bloomsbury USA Childrens
 (August 7, 2012)
2/5 Stars
    Sarah J. Maas's "Throne of Glass" is the first installment in her bestselling young adult fantasy series of the same name. While not quite reaching the stratospheric popularity of authors like Suzanne Collins or Cassandra Clare, Maas has carved out a significant following in the YA fantasy genre. The series gained particular attention when its third book won the Goodreads Choice Award for Best Young Adult Fantasy, beating out acclaimed works like Naomi Novik's "Uprooted" - a decision that raised some eyebrows given "Uprooted's" more mature themes and writing style. At its core, "Throne of Glass" follows Celaena Sardothien, an 18-year-old assassin who is offered a chance at freedom from imprisonment if she agrees to compete in a deadly contest to become the King's Champion. This premise sets up what should be a thrilling tale of intrigue, action, and high-stakes competition. However, the execution of this promising concept falls short in several key areas, creating a disconnect between the story's potential and its actual delivery. 

  The most glaring issue lies in the characterization of Celaena herself. Billed as a renowned and ruthless assassin, Celaena's actions and demeanor throughout the novel fail to convincingly portray this backstory. Instead of a hardened killer shaped by a life of violence and survival, readers are presented with a character who often comes across as naive, inexperienced, and more concerned with romantic entanglements than the life-or-death situation she finds herself in. This dissonance between Celaena's supposed background and her actual behavior is jarring and undermines the credibility of the narrative. 

  Maas's decision to make her protagonist an assassin is an intriguing one, but it's a choice that demands careful handling to maintain believability. The disconnect between Celaena's backstory and her actions suggests that perhaps a different character concept - such as a young woman with some combat training but less extreme life experiences - might have been more fitting for the story Maas ultimately tells. The assassin angle feels more like an attempt to add edginess to the character rather than an integral part of who Celaena is. 

  The love triangle that develops between Celaena, Crown Prince Dorian, and Captain of the Guard Chaol Westfall further detracts from the potential of the premise. While romantic subplots are common in YA literature, the emphasis placed on this aspect of the story overshadows the more compelling elements of political intrigue and personal growth that could have been explored. The romance often feels forced and distracts from the high-stakes competition and darker themes the novel attempts to address. 

  Prince Dorian's characterization is particularly problematic. Described as weak and ineffectual, he fails to come across as a compelling love interest or a believable heir to a powerful kingdom. This weakness in character development extends beyond Dorian, with many of the supporting cast feeling more like caricatures than fully realized individuals. 

  The novel's world-building and plot consistency also suffer from a lack of attention to detail. Inconsistencies in character behavior and motivations, along with convenient plot developments, give the impression of a hastily constructed narrative rather than a carefully crafted fantasy world. This "laziness" in storytelling, as some critics have noted, undermines the reader's ability to fully immerse themselves in the world Maas has created. 

  Despite these flaws, "Throne of Glass" does have redeeming qualities that have contributed to its popularity. Maas's writing style is engaging and accessible, making the book a quick and entertaining read for many. The basic premise of the competition is inherently exciting, and there are moments of genuine tension and intrigue scattered throughout the novel. Additionally, while Celaena's characterization may be inconsistent, her confident and sometimes brash attitude resonates with many readers who appreciate a female protagonist who isn't afraid to speak her mind. 

  The book's marketing and cover art present an interesting dichotomy. While the original cover accurately depicts the more romanticized aspects of the story, later editions feature sleeker, action-oriented designs that may attract a broader audience but also set up expectations the book doesn't fully meet. This disconnect between marketing and content speaks to a larger issue within the YA fantasy genre, where books are often packaged to appeal to both action-oriented and romance-focused readers, sometimes at the expense of narrative cohesion. 

  "Throne of Glass" seems to struggle with its identity, torn between being an action-packed fantasy and a romantic drama. This identity crisis results in a book that may disappoint readers expecting a hardcore assassin story while also potentially alienating those looking for a more traditional YA romance. The inclusion of elements like Celaena receiving a puppy mid-competition further blurs the line between the gritty world of assassins and a more lighthearted coming-of-age tale. 

 It's worth noting that many fans of the series argue that the second book, "Crown of Midnight," represents a significant improvement over its predecessor. However, for readers left unsatisfied by the first installment, the prospect of continuing the series may not be enticing enough to overcome their initial disappointment. 

 In conclusion, "Throne of Glass" is a novel with immense potential that ultimately falls short due to inconsistent characterization, an overemphasis on romance at the expense of other plot elements, and a lack of attention to world-building details. While it has found a dedicated fanbase and launched a successful series, it struggles to fully deliver on its promising premise. For readers considering diving into the world of "Throne of Glass," it's important to approach the book with measured expectations and an understanding that its strengths lie more in its entertainment value than in its depth or consistency as a fantasy narrative. Those looking for more cohesive and well-developed YA fantasy might be better served exploring other options in the genre. However, for readers who enjoy romantic elements mixed with their fantasy and are willing to overlook some inconsistencies, "Throne of Glass" may still offer an enjoyable reading experience. As with any book, individual tastes vary, and what doesn't work for some readers may resonate strongly with others. 

No comments:

Post a Comment